lessons
in english
and the alternatives
If
you're moving here to live and have children, then
you'll need to find a school for them. Happily, there are at least a dozen
private schools in and around Rome that provide grade and high school
English or bilingual education for expatriate children.
If you prefer to raise
your kids as semi-italians with a full life outside the expatriate community,
you may prefer to put them into an Italian state school, which is also
much cheaper of course.
This is a big subject, so we're not gonna go into it at much depth here,
but here's a few characteristics of Italian state schooling:
Italian children don't start school until they are six years old.
Although this is a late start, the curriculum is more intensive, ie, school
day is from 8.30am to 4.30pm, so by the time kids are sixteen or so they
will have caught up with British kids who started at four years old but
only had a school day from 9am to 3pm.
Kids have the same class teacher for the first five consecutive years
- Good for stability, but perhaps bad if they just happen to hate that
teacher.
Grade school teaching is very activity and culture rich - lots of day
trips and class drama workshops - (Italian kids are raised to be exhibitionists
and performers) The three R's are not neglected though and there's lots
of quite demanding homework.
The breadth of school
subjects at primary/grade level in Italy, is impressive, certainly when
compared to British primary schooling. By the age of eleven, your child
will have have received quite intensive introductory levels of schooling
in all the disciplines and many basic principles of science (biology,
chemistry, physics), as well as some algebraic math, and even political
and twentieth century history.
And with so many original
ancient Roman ruins in the vicinity, there are uniqueiy rich resources
for historical field trips where chuldern can expeience arcaheological
study first-hand. There are also traditional activites such as Italian
folk dancing, in which children may learn the double lessons of discipline
in teamwork combined with old-fashioned gentle courtesy between the genders.
We were also very
impressed when, on her completion of her final grade-school year, my oldest
child (along with every graduating child in the Lazio and Rome region)
was presented with a gift from the county - An elegant gift-box containing
a very large cotton Italian national flag, a music CD containnng the Italian
national anthem and five other European national anthems, and a 200-page
hardback book relating the story of how the national anthem was written,
together with a message of encouragement to the recipient as a young citizen
of Italy. Such patriotism may sound like old-fashioned nationalistic propaganda,
and perhaps it is, and yet, it's a heck of a lot better than being presented
with nothing at all.
These are all some
of the better things about Italian state schooling. Alas, there are a
few problems as well, to whch we now turn...
some problems with
italian state schools
Italian
state schools are mildly condescending towards parents in a totalitarian
communistic kind of a way - Teachers have a 'we know best' attitude towards
your child's education, and they discourage any efforts to meet with them
unless it's on their terms and at their convenience. They don't let you
keep your child's report card unless you photocopy it yourself at your
own expense. You're only allowed to keep the original for a week or so,
and then you must return it, as it's 'state property'. The report card
itself is printed on official stationary and signed, countersigned and
rubberstamped by regional inspectors in a typical display of po-faced
Italian bureaucracy.
In spite of this administrative strictness though, the day to day running
of schools is surprisingly sloppy and untidy - Stray dogs (which are many)
are allowed to roam free in the school grounds, defecating and shedding
fleas, and the caretaker/janitor at our local school is a convicted drug
dealer. Dangerous srubbishs of building and demolition debris and rubbish that
blows in from the street is allowed to pile up in quiet corners or the
building's exterior and playground and is not swept away
from one month to the next.

This
photograph of a repair made to a small gymnasium hurdle in my children's
Italian state grade (primary) school in Rome illustrates much that is
wrong with Italian state schooling, and perhaps, in some measure with
Italy in general. Firstly, an obvious lack of funds for new equipment.
We believe that the money for public facilities such as schools is in
fact there, but is syphoned off by corrupt local politicians before it
ever gets down to the grass roots where it is needed.
Secondly, a lack of intelligence or aptitude for the job by the people
actually employed in the educational field, even at the janitorial-end
of things. By any standards of mechanical and engineering knowledge, this
repair is a bad job. Not only will the join still be weak and prone to
break again, but it is in fact more dangerous now than before, for the
sharp-edged metal brackets and screws used to effect the repair could
now inflict quite a serious wound on any child unlucky enough to fall
on this hurdle and break it again.
Obviously this repair was seen as a quick, cheap way of doing the job,
yet for almost the same money, an entirely new shaft of wood could have
been cut, shaped and painted to make a safe, strong and nice-lookng repair
as good as new. However the chosen repair method demonstrates uncaring,
rushed and unintelligent workmanship by a school janitor who does not
even understand basic woodworking skills, or care about child health and
safety.
Thirdly, teaching staff themselves have evidently not noticed this inferior
and dangerous workmanship, or if they have, they do not care.
In general, it's the buggy little things in Italy such as this that illustrate
the greater sickness in society, and in particular, the bureaucratic,
public service end of things. Italian politicians and public servants
promise much, yet deliver little, and the little that they do deliver
is often defective.
In institutions such as schools, where children's little characters are
formed, it should be a priority of staff at all levels to demonstrate
care, intelligence and the pursuit of excellence, but we see this to be
lacking in our local grade school.
Our
critique of this one small item of gymnasium equipment may seem an overreaction
out of all proportion, yet please note, it is intended as merely a single
ilustration of what many Americans may perceive as a greater problem with
Italian state schooling, just one poignant item in a whole catalogue of
problems too numerous to list and discuss here, all rather sad counterpoints
to the wel-meaning and idealistic graduation gift of national flag and
anthem CD.
Parents
have to buy all their children's
notebooks and are continually requested to donate paper, glue, staples,
chalk and other stationary materials to the school. Children are not given
lockers or flip-top desks with storage space, so must carry their entire,
very heavy collection of workbooks back and forth to school in their rucksacks
(remember, these are only little children aged six to ten) Any messages
or circulars sent from the school to parent have to be copied down by
the children themselves in a special notebook - It's obviously too much
trouble for the school to purchase or use a photocopier. It's shockingly
shoddy and inefficient, demeaning to the children themselves in a way
that conditions them from formative yeas to expect, (and to give), only
second best in commercial service or business, and is overlaid with an
insultingly Big-Brother flavoured regime that little values parental input.
There
is often no toilet paper, no soap, and either soiled or no hand-towels
at all in the children's lavatories.
Most Italian mothers
don't work. Coincidentally, all parent/teacher meetings are held at around
five pm, and are thus concluded long before any working parent can commute
back home from the city to the school. Thus, these meetings are only ever
attended by a gaggle of non-professional mothers who spend the time in
gossiping small-talk and offer no real resistance or constructive criticism
of the school's policies. How very convenient for the school
Yer
pays yer money and yer takes yer choice.
We are on the whole
very pleased, impressed even, with the academic standards of Italian state
schools, but we feel this is sadly let down, perhaps even undermined in
part, by the slackness of the administrative side of things, and the prevailing
communistic flavour of this still strongly state-controlled and archaicly
totalitarian-minded institution.
...more
about schools at top of this page
|